Meet the 2024
Energy Creates Judges

1. Originality and Creativity (20 points)

Uniqueness of Concept (10 points): How original and innovative is the project idea?

• 0-2 points: The project shows no originality.
• 3-5 points: The project shows some originality but has noticeable similarities to existing ideas.
• 6-8 points: The project is mostly original with some innovative elements.
• 9-10 points: The project is highly original and innovative, offering a unique perspective.

‍

Creative Approach (10 points): How creatively is the project executed?

• 0-2 points: The execution is conventional with little creativity.
• 3-5 points: The execution shows some creativity but lacks originality in key areas.
• 6-8 points: The execution is creative with a few original elements.
• 9-10 points: The execution is highly creative and original, demonstrating exceptional innovation.

2. Relevance and Impact (20 points)

Relevance to Theme/Goals (10 points): How well does the project align with the

contest’s theme or goals?

• 0-2 points: The project is loosely related to the theme or goals.
• 3-5 points: The project aligns with the theme or goals but not strongly.
• 6-8 points: The project is relevant and aligns well with the theme or goals.
• 9-10 points: The project is highly relevant and strongly aligns with the theme or goals.

Potential Impact (10 points): What is the potential impact of the project on its intended audience or field? This can be interpreted as emotional or cognitive impact; the power of the project to ignite critical thinking.

• 0-2 points: The project is unlikely to have any significant impact.
• 3-5 points: The project has some potential impact but is limited in scope.
• 6-8 points: The project has a clear potential impact with a significant reach.
• 9-10 points: The project has a high potential impact, potentially transforming the field or
  significantly benefiting the audience.

3. Presentation and Clarity (20 points)

Clarity of Presentation (10 points): How clearly is the project presented?

• 0-2 points: The presentation is unclear and difficult to understand.
• 3-5 points: The presentation is somewhat clear but has significant gaps.
• 6-8 points: The presentation is clear with minor areas of confusion.
• 9-10 points: The presentation is exceptionally clear and easy to understand.

Professionalism (10 points): How professional is the presentation and submission?

• 0-2 points: The presentation is unprofessional and lacks polish.
• 3-5 points: The presentation is somewhat professional but lacks polish.
• 6-8 points: The presentation is professional with minor areas for improvement.
• 9-10 points: The presentation is highly professional and polished.

4. Technical Merit (20 points)

Technical Skill and Competence (20 points): How well does the project demonstrate
technical skill and competence?

• 0-4 points: The project shows little to no technical skill.
• 5-9 points: The project shows some technical skill but has noticeable flaws.
• 10-14 points: The project demonstrates strong technical skill with minor issues.
• 15-20 points: The project demonstrates exceptional technical skill and competence.

5. Wildcard Points (20 points)

Judge’s Discretion (20 points)

• Between 0-20 points awarded at the discretion of the judge.

Total Points: 100

Each criterion should be scored independently, and the total score for each project should
be the sum of the individual criteria scores. This rubric ensures a comprehensive evaluation
of each project's originality, relevance, impact, presentation, and technical merit.